Best Milk Thistle Supplement: 11 of 191 Labels Match the Trial Dose

Quick Answer: We read every single-ingredient milk thistle label in the NIH Dietary Supplement Label Database that is listed as on the market: 191 distinct products. On 102 of them (53%), including all 47 liquids, you cannot work out how much silymarin, the extract the trials tested, you would take. Of the 88 that let you calculate a daily amount, 51 give less than 420 mg a day even at the label’s maximum, the dose used in the cirrhosis trial most often cited for milk thistle, and 40 are labelled for once a day, although the trials split the dose three times a day. Only 11 products are set up exactly the way that trial gave it: 140 mg of silymarin, three times a day. Even at that dose, the two cirrhosis trials disagreed on survival, so no label can promise a liver result.
Most “best milk thistle” lists rank brands and tell you to look for “80% silymarin”. That number is a percentage of the extract, not a dose. This page sets out the doses the trials actually gave, then checks the labels against them, so you can judge any bottle yourself. For what milk thistle has and has not been shown to do, see our milk thistle benefits review.
What the trials gave: about 140 mg of silymarin, three times a day
The milk thistle trial most often cited for the liver is Ferenci 1989 in the Journal of Hepatology. 170 people with cirrhosis took either silymarin or a placebo; the treated group “received 140 mg silymarin three times daily”. Four-year survival was 58% on silymarin and 39% on placebo (P = 0.036).
A larger trial did not repeat that result. Parés 1998 gave 200 people with alcohol-related cirrhosis “450 mg of silymarin (150 mg/ three times per day)” or a placebo, and survival was similar in the two groups: 15 deaths on silymarin and 14 on placebo during the trial.
The NIH-funded SyNCH trial (JAMA 2012) went higher on purpose: 420 mg or 700 mg of silymarin “administered 3 times per day”, that is 1,260 or 2,100 mg a day, in people with hepatitis C. Its authors called these “higher than customary doses”, and they did not lower liver enzymes more than placebo.
So the dose that has been tested is roughly 420 to 450 mg of silymarin a day, split into three doses, with SyNCH as the high-dose exception. Across these trials, it is the dose and the schedule that are consistent. The results are not.
What the labels give
We counted a label’s daily silymarin as the amount it states, or, where it gives an extract weight and a standardization such as “80% silymarin”, that percentage of the extract. We then multiplied by the label’s maximum number of servings per day.
| What the label lets you work out | Products (of 191) |
|---|---|
| No silymarin amount and no standardization, so the dose cannot be calculated | 102 |
| of which liquids (tinctures, glycerites) | 47 of 47 liquids |
| A daily silymarin amount can be calculated | 88 |
| below 200 mg a day | 14 |
| 200 to 419 mg a day | 37 |
| 420 to 1,259 mg a day (the cirrhosis-trial range and above) | 36 |
| 1,260 mg a day or more (SyNCH’s lower dose) | 1 |
One further product states a silymarin amount per serving but not how many servings a day, so it is not in either count. The median daily amount among the 88 is 400 mg.
Two patterns stand out. First, 40 of the 88 are labelled for a single serving a day, and 34 of those 40 deliver less than 420 mg. The trials split the dose across the day, and no trial we found tested the whole amount at once. Second, 103 of the 191 labels mention the liver, detox or cleansing, and 43 of those give no silymarin amount at all.
Only 2 of the 191 are phytosome products, the form that binds silybin to phosphatidylcholine for better absorption. Many “best” lists recommend phytosomes, but the trials above used conventional silymarin extracts, so a phytosome dose cannot be checked against them directly.
The 11 labels that match the cirrhosis-trial schedule
These products state 175 mg of milk thistle extract standardized to 80% silymarin, which is 140 mg of silymarin, and tell you to take one capsule three times a day: the Ferenci schedule exactly.
| Brand | Product (as listed) |
|---|---|
| Nature’s Way | Thisilyn Milk Thistle Extract |
| Nature’s Answer | Milk Thistle |
| Sundown Naturals | Milk Thistle; Milk Thistle 175 mg |
| Puritan’s Pride | Milk Thistle Extract 175 mg |
| The Vitamin Shoppe | Milk Thistle Extract 175 mg |
| NutraBio | Milk Thistle 175 Milligrams |
| Radiance | Silymarin Milk Thistle 175 mg |
| Origin | Standardized Extract Milk Thistle 175 mg |
| AN Amazing Nutrition | Milk Thistle 175 mg |
| green fortune | Milk Thistle |
Matching the schedule only means the product is set up to be taken the way it was tested. It does not mean the product contains what the label says; our label count cannot check that, and the database records each label as it was when entered (entries here run from 2011 to 2025).
What the European regulator allows it for
The European Union herbal monograph on milk thistle fruit (EMA/HMPC/294187/2013, June 2018) accepts it only as a traditional herbal medicine, for “symptomatic relief of digestive disorders, sensation of fullness and indigestion and to support the liver function, after serious conditions have been excluded by a medical doctor”. The monograph does not accept a well-established use based on clinical trials. It also says it is not recommended for anyone under 18, that symptoms lasting more than two weeks need a doctor, and that people allergic to the daisy family should not take it.
In other words, if you have liver disease, the regulator’s position is that milk thistle is not a substitute for seeing a doctor, and the trials above, in people who did have liver disease, gave mixed results.
If you want to take it at the tested dose
Both of these are among the 11 labels above: 175 mg of extract standardized to 80% silymarin (140 mg), one capsule three times a day. Neither has been tested as a product in a clinical trial.
Nature’s Way Thisilyn Milk Thistle Extract: the label says one capsule three times daily, before meals.
Puritan’s Pride Milk Thistle Extract 175 mg: 175 mg extract at 80% silymarin per capsule.
Disclosure: these are Amazon affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We chose products whose label states the silymarin dose the trials used; we did not include liquids, because none of the 47 in the database states a silymarin amount. Labels change, so check the one on the product you receive. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
How we did this
On 17 November 2026 we searched the NIH Dietary Supplement Label Database for “milk thistle”, kept labels listed as on the market whose only active ingredient is milk thistle or its extract, and downloaded each full label. Repeat versions with the same brand and product name were counted once, leaving 191 products. Daily silymarin is the stated silymarin amount per serving, or the extract weight multiplied by the stated standardization percentage, multiplied by the label’s maximum servings per day. A label counted as mentioning the liver if its claims or name mentioned the liver, detox or cleansing. The search returns labels in relevance order and is capped, so a few single-ingredient products may be missing.
Sources
- Ferenci P, et al. Randomized controlled trial of silymarin treatment in patients with cirrhosis of the liver. J Hepatol. 1989;9(1):105-13. PMID 2671116. Checked November 2026.
- Parés A, et al. Effects of silymarin in alcoholic patients with cirrhosis of the liver. J Hepatol. 1998;28(4):615-21. PMID 9566830. Checked November 2026.
- Fried MW, et al. Effect of silymarin (milk thistle) on liver disease in patients with chronic hepatitis C unsuccessfully treated with interferon therapy. JAMA. 2012;308(3):274-82. PMID 22797645. Checked November 2026.
- European Medicines Agency, Committee on Herbal Medicinal Products. European Union herbal monograph on Silybum marianum (L.) Gaertn., fructus. EMA/HMPC/294187/2013, 5 June 2018. Checked November 2026.
- National Institutes of Health, Office of Dietary Supplements. Dietary Supplement Label Database. Queried 17 November 2026.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best milk thistle supplement?
The one whose label lets you check the dose against the trials: about 140 mg of silymarin three times a day, as in the cirrhosis trials. Of 191 US single-ingredient milk thistle products we read, 11 are set up exactly that way, and 102 give no way to work out the silymarin dose at all.
How much milk thistle should I take a day?
The cirrhosis trials gave 420 to 450 mg of silymarin a day, split into three doses. A US trial in hepatitis C gave 1,260 or 2,100 mg a day and found no benefit over placebo. Check the silymarin amount, not the milk thistle amount: 175 mg of an 80% extract is 140 mg of silymarin.
What does “80% silymarin” mean on a milk thistle label?
It means 80% of the extract’s weight is silymarin. It tells you the concentration, not the dose. You need the extract weight as well: 175 mg at 80% gives 140 mg of silymarin per capsule, while 100 mg at 80% gives 80 mg.
Is milk thistle tincture as good as capsules?
You cannot tell from the label. None of the 47 liquid milk thistle products in the NIH label database states a silymarin amount, so there is no way to compare a tincture’s dose with the trials.
Should I take milk thistle once a day or three times a day?
The trials split the dose three times a day. 40 of the 88 products we could calculate are labelled for once a day, and 34 of those deliver less than the 420 mg a day the cirrhosis trials used.


